Kevin reconnects with the mystery woman, and they decide that Lucy and Kevin's Christmas party will provide the perfect setting for an introduction. (Dec 10th)

Lucy interferes with Kevin's secret relationship. Lucy catches Kevin purchasing a scarf at Wyndhams for the mystery woman, and Lucy assumes that the scarf is for her. Later, Kevin covers when Lucy finds him purchasing an identical scarf, and Lucy stirs up more potential trouble by inviting herself back to the
lighthouse. (Dec 12th
 

Livvie celebrates when she believes Lucy and Kevin are reconciled and will marry each other. However, Kevin disappoints both Livvie and Lucy when he tells Livvie that marriage remains a possibility only in the distant future, if at all. Lucy shares with Livvie her
suspicions that Kevin intends to have a surprise wedding on Christmas, but Lucy freaks when she eavesdrops on Kevin's phone call and realizes that Kevin has another woman waiting in the wings. (Dec 13th)
 

Lucy slyly questions Kevin about his telephone call. Unsatisfied, Lucy ends up spying on Kevin, and Lucy discovers Kevin in the park with a woman wearing the scarf Lucy picked out for Kevin to give to Livvie. (Dec 14th)